Donald Trump

In a text webchat on the Guardian website today, writer and filmmaker John Pilger praised Donald Trump as a man who is “speaking straight” to Americans, and is “making sense”.

Though Pilger condemned his views on immigration as “gross”, he said they were no worse “in essence” to that of Cameron’s views.

He also said that at least Trump was telling the truth on Iraq, wasn’t planning to invade anywhere and “not beholden to Israel”.

Here’s what Pilger wrote in full, in response to being asked his take on Trump:

Trump is speaking straight to ordinary Americans, not through the usual media/liberal filter. He is making sense to a lot of people. They like his absence of hypocrisy and the fact that he’s prepared to say George W. Bush committed a war crime in invading Iraq.

Apart from his gross views on immigration – though no more gross in essence than, say, David Cameron’s – he is not planning to invade anywhere, he doesn’t hate the Russians or the Chinese, he is not beholden to Israel. People like this lack of cant, and when the so-called liberal media deride him, they like him even more.

In response to different question on Putin, Pilger said:

Compared with Obama, Cameron and the rest, he’s [Putin] the most intelligent by far.

We would suggest that Pilger do a bit more research into Trump’s views.

Earlier, Trump had said he would be “neutral” between Israel and Palestine.

Then in a more recent interview with Fox News, Trump said he saw Israel as the main victim in that conflict.

100% I’d come to their [Israel’s] defense. 100%. Now, you know that under the Iran deal… but under the Iran deal, if Israel ends up attacks Iran because they’re — they see they’re doing the nuclear, or if it’s the other way around, we have to fight with Iran.

Is that what Pilger meant when he praised Trump’s “absence of hypocrisy”?

  1. The Rightwing in America and Europe are blaming the Saudi Alliance for Syria and advocating ditching the Arabs and joining Russia and Iran in a drive against jihadists. Sounds sensible to me!

  2. I like Pilger but I dont think he’s given any depth of thought about Trump – the guy is just a BS-er — yes he has tapped into the everyman in USA’s annoyance over normal politics but the guy (Trump) lacks any real policies any depth whatsoever

    its no use just saying the established way of doing politics is crap but to offer NOTHING to replace it is just stupid

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.


Comments are limited to 1000 characters.