UPDATE 20:05 A few more emails have now been leaked to leaked to LabourList, who have also reproduced our first batch.
UPDATE 23:50 Amazing to see some of these on Newsnight of all places!

The following email appeared on LobbyDog at 16:24:

Dear Geoff

I can only imagine you have taken leave of your senses. God knows what harm you have caused with your indulgence. I am sure your view is not shared by the majority of the PLP or ordinary party members who you arrogantly assume should have no say in this process. I am sure there will be no appetite for your proposed distraction and it will disappear as quickly as your credibility.

Yours fraternally
John Heppell

A whole bunch more of that thread has now been leaked to Scrapbook:

Steve Pound:

In my opinion the forming of a circular firing squad is never a good idea. You don’t just shoot yourself in the foot you wound the Party – and,more importantly, those who depend on Labour.

Steve Pound MP

Andy Love:

John [Heppell],

I share your anger and frustration at the indulgence of our two colleagues and the distraction that it has caused. Whatever their motivation it is difficult to believe that they had the interests of the Labour Party uppermost in their minds. Now that we are into the New Year we should be fighting the Tories and not ourselves.

Diane Abbott:

Dear Geoff
I do not always agree with John Heppell. But I, also, can only assume that you have taken leave of your senses.

Barbara Follett:

As someone who has known and worked closely with you both for over two decades, I am more disappointed than I can say by this unwise and totally uncalled for e-mail. I am also at a loss to know how people of your obvious intelligence, experience and achievement could possibly view it as helpful.

It fuels the speculation and uncertainty you purport to want to end and, worst of all, it betrays the very causes you have spent your lives fighting for.  I do not know what led you to do this but I do know that in sending this e-mail you have lost my respect.

We have been promised more by our source. Follow @psbook for updates.

  1. Pingback: jenweb
  2. Pingback: Labour List
  3. Pingback: labourmatters
  4. Pingback: Mags
  5. Pingback: topsy_top20k
  6. Pingback: Mohammed Ahmed
  7. Pingback: Rowan Singh
  8. Pingback: Brian McGuinness
  9. Pingback: Liat Norris
  10. Pingback: Kira
  11. I think Steve Pound has got a bit confused there to be honest. How are you going to shoot yourself in the foot in a circular firing squad?!


  12. Pingback: Andrew Chadwick
  13. Pingback: Andrew Lomas
  14. Pingback: Phelim
  15. Pingback: Maria Barrett
  16. Pingback: Steve Cockburn
  17. I’m torn between my excitement over Labour’s autocannibalism, and my joy at seeing Geoff Hoon’s rough treatment at the hands of his colleagues. The man was a disgrace as defence secretary.

    Excellent scoop. Will be interesting to see who else is sticking the knife in!

  18. Ha quite, I meant in terms of the people who depend on Labour. As for the circular firing squad.. I’m thinking we should give the shadow cabinet some toys that shoot out sucker things to test out his theory.

  19. Pingback: Leon Green
  20. Pingback: CathElliott
  21. Pingback: Kate Sang
  22. Pingback: John Chilver
  23. I’m depending on Labour losing the next GE. Otherwise UK plc goes bust and more young men and women lose their lives in meaningless wars that Brown voted for but, as Chancellor and then (unelected) PM, refused to adequately resource. Blood. On. Hands.

  24. Love Pound’s comment.

    JimJam, UK PLC would have gone bust if we didn’t prop up Northern Rock. To have any effect, you can only choose between us or the people who would have let British capitalism collapse.

    Whether you like it or not, that’s true.

  25. Pingback: Simon Taylor
  26. Pingback: Jenna
  27. Bahookey Maguire says:

    The fact remains , plot or not as soon as the elections over Brown WILL be replaced by either Balls, Mandelson or another slithering snake. Another unelected egostistic cretin.

    Grassroots Labour party members and trade unionists really need to seize back control of their party and remond the tail who the dog is that wags it. Either by canceling membership making sure your union dues and political levvies do not go to Labour.

    The party is no longer the party of the working man, it lost that title a long time back.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.


Comments are limited to 1000 characters.