Tag Archives: harriet harman

Gingergate: SNP court redhead vote after Harman comments

Harriet Harman’s oddly personal (but nonetheless amusing) attack on Chief Secretary to the Treasury Danny Alexander, whom she called a “ginger rodent”, has generated a minor storm for which she’s been forced to apologise.

Some commentators have been highlighting the hypocrisy of a life-long champion of equality mocking a man for a physical trait. Others like Mike Smithson have suggested that Labour might have lost the ginger vote (because we all know ginger people all vote in a block.) However not content to stand on the sidelines and chuckle the SNP rolled out comely redhead Shirley-Anne Somerville MSP to condemn the remark as “anti Scottish”:

“Scotland probably has the highest proportion of redheads in the world”

Perhaps the SNP would do well to heed the wisdom of Napoleon Bonaparte:

Never interrupt your enemy while he’s making a mistake.

Shadow Cabinet elections in graphs

Labour’s Shadow Cabinet elections got busier again yesterday with at least two more hopefuls (including Mike Gapes and Wayne David) sending out emails to their parliamentary colleagues. Following changes to the PLP rules women can count on a minimum of seven places at the top table. Including Harriet Harman this means a minimum of six will be elected from the Commons, as shown below:


Though the proportion of women running for shadow cabinet is approximately the same as the men, there are far fewer female incumbents looking for a return. Yvette Cooper and Tessa Jowell are the only two women from the Brown ministry seeking election to the shadow cabinet, in addition to Rosie Winterton, who has been shadowing the Leader of the House of Commons following Harriet Harman’s temporary accession to the leadership.

Amongst the men, however, there are 14 male incumbents expected to run for a maximum of 13 places (see above). Scrapbook understands that the likes of Steven Twigg, Chris Bryant and David Lammy have worked the new intake hard making it increasingly likely that a number of incumbent shadow cabinet males won’t win election in a few weeks.

Therefore if you’re a female member of the Parliamentary Labour Party your chances of promotion are far greater than if you’re a man.

Here’s hoping they’re not just window dressing!

Shadow Cabinet update: Alan Johnson to run

Former Home Secretary Alan Johnson has declared he is to run for the Shadow Cabinet in the forthcoming elections. It had previously been thought that Mr. Johnson would follow top-cabinet colleagues like Alastair Darling and Jack Straw in stepping back from the political front line.

Johnson’s decision could potentially scupper the Shadow Cabinet plans of leadership contenders as it would be hard to sideline such a high profile and popular figure. Since Scrapbook last covered the Shadow Cabinet elections it has become increasingly clear who the major players are and what jobs they fancy.

In the event of a Miliband (D) victory Douglas Alexander is being lined up as a potential Shadow Foreign Secretary, with fellow Scot (and campaign organiser) Jim Murphy being considered for either Defence or Work and Pensions.Harriet Harman is rumoured to be getting the Justice brief regardless of who wins, and though he fancies the Shadow Chancellorship speculation is rife that Ed balls is being lined up as a Shadow Home Secretary – a prospect that may have been scuppered by Johnson’s announcement.

Top posts are filling up fast.

And this is before trying to squeeze in whichever of the Milibrothers comes second.

Harriet Harman rules out future leadership bid

LabourList: Harman rules out leadership bid

LabourList is reporting that Harriet Harman has ruled out a potential bid for the Labour leadership. In an interview with Andew Neil for Straight Talk to be broadcast this weekend, the deputy leader says she “absolutely” would not stand should a vacancy arise. PoliticsHome has the full exchange:

Andrew Neil: So, if a vacancy should arise for the leadership of your party you will not stand?
Harriett Harman: No, not.
AN: Under any circumstances?
HH: I’ve said so, absolutely not.
AN: If asked, will refuse; if nominated, will decline?
HH: Absolutely.

Looking for some background, Scrapook stumbled this BetFair blog post on Labour’s leadership contenders from August this year, when Harman was the favourite:

Labour’s current deputy has a vitriolic relationship with most of the press, and will undoubtedly be presented as an electoral disaster waiting to happen by certain commentators. That shouldn’t, however, make much of a difference to her chances of becoming the party’s next leader. Rather than being decided by the press or the wider voting public, this contest will be decided by Labour’s tripartite electoral college system, made up of MPs, party members and trade unionists.

Unlike any of her rivals, Harman has already shown she has enough support to win via that electoral college by beating five others for the deputy’s post. She has a long history of activism within the labour movement, and it can only help that her husband is the respected leading trade unionist Jack Dromey. She could well be the most left-wing candidate on the ballot paper at a time when the party wants to move back towards its socialist roots.

Two more factors favour Harman. As possibly the only woman in the contest, she has a strong base of female MPs and members who think its high time the party were led a woman. Secondly, Harman is one of the very few Labour MPs in a safe enough seat to survive an increasingly plausible wipe-out.

Verdict: A very strong contender, especially if the party loses badly, therefore eliminating potential challengers.

Harman is still second favourite with Ladbrokes at 9/2 but has already dropped to fourth on Betfair, behind Alan Johnson and the Milibands.

Sorry for lack of blogs today. Too many political irons in too many fires!

  • GMB Remploy campaign
  • Follow us on Twitter