Tag Archives: afzal anwar

Liberal Democrat ethnic minority candidates: those odds in full

Horsey man John McCririck

This aftertoon Nick Clegg told the Liberal Democrats’ annual conference that he wants “to live in a country where prejudice, insularity and fear are conquered by the great British traditions of tolerance, pluralism and justice”. Unfortunately appeals to pluralism sit uneasy alongside the fact that the Lib Dems don’t have a single black or Asian MP or MEP.

In fairness, however, a blog on the lack of any BME candidates for the top-25 Liberal target seats sparked a pretty decent debate in the comments:

This is an issue; we should have done more, sooner. We didn’t. We didn’t because we had an internal row over what to do and ended up doing nothing. That’s not right, but it’s the kind of mess-up that democracies have from time to time – Lib Dem blogger Richard Gadsden

So there are four Asian PPCs in their top 100 target seats. It’s one thing staring at majorities but the nice traders at Ladbrokes who were very helpful in pricing up these constituencies especially for Scrapbook (remarkably short odds for Manchester Gorton given the majority):

Parmjit Singh Gill

Target #29: Leicester South – Parmjit Singh Gill – 11/10

Qassim Afzal

Target #73: Manchester Gorton – Qassim Afzal – 6/4

Zuffar Haq

Target #31: Harborough – Zuffar Haq – 8/1

Afzal Anwar

Target #53: Pendle – Afzal Anwar – 40/1

Although Gill may break through in Leicester, this spread shows the Liberal Democrats have clearly failed to get serious on BME candidates. To make matters worse, they have now missed the selection boat and the issue will be hanging around their necks like a massive “kick me” sign until after next May. Scrapbook has already spoken to one Labour election agent whose draw dropped at the Liberal’s precarious position on this.

This is a gift horse for the other parties in tight Asian-heritage council seats.

Hideously white: no ethnic minority candidates for Liberal Democrats in top 25 target seats

Nick Clegg, Lynne Featherstone and Parmjit Singh Gill

Last year the Liberal Democrat frontbencher Jenny Willot had the cheek to claim that “Labour are failing on ethnic minority employment”. Perhaps the so-called ‘real opposition’ should start by employing some ethnic minorities on their own green benches?

As Iain Dale blogged yesterday, Liberal Democrats do not have a single MP (or MEP for that matter) from a black or Asian background. The post was in response to comments from Lynne Featherstone, who was asked why this was the case:

“We don’t have any safe seats where you can just place people, you have to earn your spurs in the Lib Dems.” – Lynne Featherstone

Featherstone’s complacency clearly runs through the party’s top brass, which has no ethnic minority candidates in their top 25 target seats and only one in a conceivably winnable constituency. Plumbing the dark depths of the Liberal Democrats top 100 PPCs only turns up a total of just four minority candidates. In contrast, Labour have 12 black and asian MPs already. The Conservatives have two with an expection of  increasing this significantly in May 2010.

The only ethnic minority Liberal Democrat MP was Parmjit Singh Gill. Gill won a by-election in their current 29th target seat of Leicester South 2004 only to be beaten by Labour a year later at the general election.  He is contesting the constituency once more and a swing of 4.4% away from Labour would overturn a majority of 3,725 and see Gill returned to Westminster again. Assuming the Tories hold off marginal challenges from the Liberals, a swing of this magnitude would see Cleggover gain ten seats.

But no one else has a hope in hell. Zuffar Haq would need to unseat Tory Edward Garnier in Harborough (target #31), who, completely untainted by the expenses scandal, is sitting pretty with a majority of 3,892 and an inevitable national swing to the Conservatives. The other two PPCs are Afzal Anwar in Pendle (target #53) and Qassim Afzal in Manchester Gorton (target #73).

Gregg Dyke once said that the BBC was “hideously white”.

You can add the Liberal Democrats to that list.

  • GMB Remploy campaign
  • Follow us on Twitter