At 8:30pm last night, an article entitled Guardian gagged from reporting parliament appeared on the newspaper’s website. Twelve hours later, Trafigura – a large but inconspicuous trader in oil and base metals – was on the lips of bloggers and tweeters everywhere along with Carter Ruck, their libel lawyers.
- Just before 10pm Guido reproduces the parliamentary question the Guardian had been blocked from printing, inviting Carter-Ruck to sue him in Nevis, where his blog is incorporated.
- With “British Press Banned From Reporting Parliament. Seriously“, The Spectator becomes the first mainstream media outlet to print the question.
- The other big-boy right wing bloggers pile in, including Tory Bear with characteristic humour.
- Next Left’s brilliantly sarcastic post was presciently titled Carter-Ruck vs. the blogosphere.
- Scrapbook uncovered the select committee evidence that alerted Paul Farrelly, the MP who tabled the ‘unreportable question’, to Trafigura.
The story took off overnight on Twitter, thanks largely to a gargantuan effort by Morus, who deputises for Mike Smithson at Political Betting.
- While mainstream online news outlets wouldn’t touch the story, Alan Rusbridger tweeted at 9:49 am that the Guardian planned to challenge the Carter-Ruck in the High Court today.
- Left Foot Forward become the first site to pull together a cohesive analyisis and early narrative of the story.
- Mr Eugenides highlights the debacle as an example of the Streisland effect, where attempts to stifle a story backfire completely by generating yet more adverse publicity.
- Urgent questions are table by the Liberal Democrats in Parliament.
- At 12:53 Rusbridger announces – again via Twitter – that Carter-Ruck have backed down.
“One day these highly-remunerated libel lawyers are going to wake up and realise that they aren’t being paid in guineas any more and that, thanks to this thing called the Interwebs, they can’t shut down freedom of speech the way they used to in the old days.” – Mr Eugenides
The BBC, Channel 4 New et al should pick this up now.
This can’t happen again.
UPDATE: A few post-mortems around but The Daily Quail’s Carter-Ruck school of viral marketing is definitely the funniest.









3 Comments
Guido was NOT the first onto this last night. See http://onlinejournalismblog.com/2009/10/13/trafigura-guardian-gagging-order-parliament/
Didn’t intend to give that impression. Presumed others had spotted it first but he was the first “name blog” to weigh in – plus he printed the question itself.
Wow – thanks for the hat-tip, PS! I can’t justifiably take any more credit that the other Twitterers who were there at the beginning, especially @jackofkent and @dontgetfooled, but it’s the fact that so many people cared about this when most of the US (including myself) had gone to sleep (and stopped tweeting baseball) that it got into the Top Trends. They were the ones who took it from 3rd in the UK to the top 4 on Twitter globally, and forced it into the big limelight.
A good day for freedom of the press all round, and for a rare and fruitful alliance between the MSM and the blogosphere! Long may it continue…
4 Trackbacks
New post –> How the blogosphere vs Trafigura and Carter-Ruck unfolded http://cli.gs/ehVqJ
RT @psbook: How the blogosphere vs #Trafigura and #CarterRuck unfolded http://cli.gs/ehVqJ
RT @psbook How the blogosphere vs #Trafigura and #Carter-Ruck unfolded http://bit.ly/YHgDy <<< and with that, I'll let it go…for now…
RT:: @BBCTech How #Twitter toppled a UK court injunction http://bit.ly/XGVFv | Interstng blog on #Trafigura & #CarterRuck http://url.ie/2n38